Understanding: A Bitcoin ETF is Not Your Actual Bitcoin

Jonathan Stoker Feb 02, 2024, 19:20pm 67 views

Understanding: A Bitcoin ETF is Not Your Actual Bitcoin

US Bitcoin ETFs: A Stepping Stone to Crypto's True Potential

In recent times, the U.S. has seen a surge in the popularity of newly approved BitcoinBitcoin$42,260 -0.64% Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs). This popularity is evidenced by the robust trading volume and flow metrics associated with these funds. But, it's important to note that these ETFs don't offer the genuine utility of Bitcoin - the facilitation of peer-to-peer transactions and the ability to bypass traditional intermediaries.

The Drawbacks of Bitcoin ETFs

Investing in a Bitcoin ETF only provides exposure to Bitcoin's price, without actual ownership of the asset. As such, ETF investors don't enjoy the key elements of Bitcoin's original purpose: enabling financial ownership and sovereignty for all. This was the vision of Satoshi Nakamoto, Bitcoin's anonymous creator, when he penned the Bitcoin white paper 15 years ago.

One of the main pitfalls of Bitcoin ETFs is their replication of our outdated financial system, which is built on obsolete technologies. By depending on intermediaries, Bitcoin ETFs reintroduce the counterparty risks that have been a staple in finance for decades. Examples of these risks include traditional players like Lehman Brothers and more recent entities such as FTXFTX$3.28 -5.38% or Silicon Valley Bank, who have mismanaged client assets, leading to billions of dollars in losses.

Breaking Away from Traditional Finance

Cryptocurrency offers an escape from this flawed, archaic system, which currently satisfies a mere 9% of Americans. Besides the inherent counterparty risks, Bitcoin ETF investors are also trapped within the U.S.-centric financial system. This is in stark contrast to crypto's main selling point, which enables unrestricted access to a permissionless network and benefits from a previously unheard-of level of decentralization.

Further, Bitcoin ETF investors are deprived of owning a key component of crypto - a private key. This secret, algorithmically-generated code is the sole proof users own their digital tokens. Holding these keys is the only method people can interact with the world of crypto, own Bitcoin, participate in decentralized finance, and use decentralized apps with ownership and freedom. In comparison, ETFs cannot provide this feature.

The Hidden Costs of Bitcoin ETFs

Apart from contradicting crypto's utility, Bitcoin ETFs are more costly than the preferable choice of secure self-custody. With Bitcoin ETFs, investors pay fees between 0.2% to 1.5%, yet still don't own the underlying asset. There is also a pressing need for security amongst corporate entities and individuals joining the crypto sphere. Financial intermediaries involved in ETFs bear the responsibility of safeguarding clients' assets and must implement suitable security and governance frameworks to prevent major losses.

The Benefits of Bitcoin ETFs

Despite these drawbacks, Bitcoin ETFs are not wholly disadvantageous for crypto. These traditional financial instruments can serve Bitcoin in several ways.

Firstly, they have the potential to significantly popularize Bitcoin, bringing crypto exposure to a fresh wave of entrants. Advertising for Bitcoin ETFs across the U.S. indicates their effectiveness as marketing tools for Bitcoin. Additionally, the acceptance of Bitcoin in top-tier financial systems makes it more difficult for skeptics to disregard this crypto protocol as a tool for illicit activities.

Secondly, Bitcoin ETFs can act as gateways to crypto's true promise of self-custody, similar to the role centralized exchanges have played in recent years. It's conceivable that a virtuous cycle may develop, where millions get ETF exposure to Bitcoin, discover the advantages of digital ownership, and ultimately choose to exercise genuine self-sovereignty.

Bitcoin ETFs and the Future of Crypto

While Bitcoin ETFs may merely be a form of window-dressing, they represent a tangible stepping stone towards the true promise of crypto ownership and sovereignty.

The future of Bitcoin is not to become a speculative asset confined to ETF-like investment vehicles for mainstream investors. Instead, it's a paradigm shift destined to redefine digital ownership and transform value exchange - much like the internet revolutionized information exchange.

Currently, people are only starting to comprehend the breadth of possibilities the crypto revolution offers. This revolution is more marathon than sprint, and Bitcoin ETFs are but one step on the journey towards crypto-enabled financial freedom. The true potential of crypto will only be realized when everyday users have genuine sovereignty over their assets.

Edited by Jonathan Stoker

How do you like the article?

Join the discussion on

You may also like


Articles in same category


Coins in same category


Join our community

Help moderate our articles, rate content and show your support!

We want you to be part of the first automated crypto-magazine.

Join us today